Carlos María Solare visits the Neue Synagoge in Mainz, Germany, for a performance of Martinů, Halvorsen, Schnittke, Mendelssohn, Reger and Caroline Shaw on 16 November 2025

First among equals: David Aaron Carpenter (second right) and students. Photo: Villa Musica/Maike Hessedenz

First among equals: David Aaron Carpenter (second right) and students. Photo: Villa Musica/Maike Hessedenz

For almost four decades, the foundation Villa Musica has been making an important contribution to musical life in the Federal State of Rhineland-Palatinate through a chamber music programme that sees hand-picked students rehearsing and performing alongside mentors of the calibre of – to mention just violists – Nils Mönkemeyer, Tabea Zimmermann and, in this case, David Aaron Carpenter.

Looking not a year older than his charges, Carpenter didn’t noticeably assume a leading role, being happy – all the work having been done – simply to let the music emerge (in a touching speech, he spoke of the students as his ‘colleagues’).

The concert’s first half was bookended by a vital reading of Martinů’s Madrigals by Carpenter and violinist Yan Li, and a virtuoso performance of Halvorsen’s Sarabande con Variazioni on a theme by Handel. Here Carpenter was partnered by violinist Sonja Bogner, the two striking sparks off each other in the ever-more-intricate variations, culminating in an unashamedly over-the-top coda.

Cellist Pablo Laporev joined Bogner and Carpenter for Schnittke’s String Trio, for which completely new sounds were found, crunching non-vibrato dissonances alternating with heart-on-sleeve songfulness.

The complete group came together for a passionate interpretation of Mendelssohn’s F minor String Quartet op.80, but not before Carpenter had contributed two solo spots of uncommon beauty and brilliance.

Reger’s potentially sprawling G minor Suite received a well-structured, refreshingly light reading with vibrant double-stops and some magical pianissimo touches, while Carpenter displayed a wealth of colours in the chordal pizzicato passages of Caroline Shaw’s Tallis-inspired In manus tuas.

CARLOS MARÍA SOLARE