Masterclass: Mendelssohn Variations Op 17

Guy Johnston 3

British cellist Guy Johnston talks about dialogue, contrast and sense of line in the German composer’s Classical–Romantic work

Mendelssohn wrote this work for his brother Paul in 1829, when the composer was 20. As we can see from the music, Paul must have been an accomplished amateur cellist! There are some tricky moments, but overall it is wonderfully lyrical and reminiscent of his Song without Words: it’s real chamber music, with a delightful dialogue between piano and cello. There is a feeling of tenderness and happy memory, and a sense that all’s well that ends well. It also has a nice connection with England, because Mendelssohn took it with him on his first sojourn there that same year. The cello was still gaining popularity at this time and it is interesting that here the cello part begins in a traditional, meandering gamba style to support the piano theme; but that gradually it rises up out of the depths into a virtuosic, leading role. There is a sense of development throughout: it starts calmly and warmly in a flowing D major Andante, then gathers momentum after Variations 1 and 2, into the più vivace Variation 3, allegro con fuoco Variation 4 and eventually the presto Variation 7, by which time Mendelssohn has built up a real storm before returning to calm in Variation 8. Be mindful of changes in inflection, bowings and phrase markings where material is repeated, but don’t let these get in the way of the theme. In the end the shape of each phrase governs itself: the markings just hint as to where the line is going, rather than giving explicit instructions. As you play, try also to have a feeling of improvisation and freedom in the moment. Keep the sense of an arc through from the opening theme to the final resolution. Inside that, of course, there’s a lot of fun and variation to be had.

The main theme

This is a beautifully balanced and traditional theme, in Classical–Romantic style. Mendelssohn shares the melody between the instruments and it is very charming, with smiling shapes and curves that give a real sense of sunshine. The dialogue is filled with questions and answers, and the cascading lines remind me of religious music and ringing bells. Aim for a natural tempo that feels right to you, and don’t play any quieter than piano: this is the first thing the audience hears and it needs to sound alive – particularly from bar 9, where the cello takes over the theme.

Subscribe now to keep reading …

This article is available exclusively to subscribers – subscribe now

Already subscribed? Please sign in

Strad subscription

We’re delighted that you are enjoying our website. To access this content you need to be a subscriber.

As a subscriber you’ll receive:

  • Monthly issues* packed with news, interviews and features
  • Special supplements including Accessories, Degrees, Cremona and String Courses
  • A monthly digital edition and an archive of online issues going back to January 2010
  • Full access to all premium online content on
  • Two posters a year and the annual Strad Directory*

*To receive the posters, the Strad Directory and issues and supplements in print, you will need to take out a print + online package

 If you are not ready to subscribe, register now to enjoy a selection of free content (excludes premium subscriber-only articles)