The Strad's experts evaluate the latest string recordings
Schubert: Violin Sonatas in D major D384, A minor D385, G minor D408 & A major D574
A successful start to a historically informed Schubert cycle
Friday, 26 October 2012
Jacqueline Ross (violin) Maggie Cole (fortepiano)
NAXOS 9.70164 (STREAMING/DOWNLOAD ONLY from WWW.NAXOS.COM)
Schubert’s three op.137 sonatas were downgraded to sonatinas after his death. Here they have their dignity restored, but are performed with a lighter touch than many players afforded them under their old title. The D major Sonata is sprightly and delicate, with understated but nicely shaped phrasing, the staccato passages bubbling with crisp vitality. There is plaintive but caressing playing in the Andante. The more substantial A minor Sonata receives subtle shading of dynamics and dramatic contrasts, highlighting the sudden changes of emotional gear in the opening Allegro moderato. The three movements that follow are all quite gentle: there is an easy, wistful flow to the Andante; the trio of the Menuetto is thoughtful, almost tentative, and the final Allegro has a melancholy tinge. The second movement of the G minor opens with an old-fashioned courtliness, before becoming darker and more highly coloured, and the duo performs the Menuetto with gusto.
With the A major Sonata, written a year later, Schubert’s palette had broadened. Jacqueline Ross brings a vocal expressiveness to the opening melody, and in the scherzo second movement (Schubert had upgraded from the minuet), the players scamper and tussle with sparkling vigour and wit. There is an air of wonder to the Andantino before an ebullient finale. This is all fine playing, with great musical teamwork. The balance between instruments is good, in an acoustic providing space and clarity.
From the October 2012 issue. Subscribe to The Strad or download our digital edition as part of a 30-day free trial.