The Strad's experts evaluate the latest string recordings
Il Progetto Vivaldi 3. Vivaldi: Cello Concertos in A minor, F major & D major, Concerto for two mandolins in G major (arr. S. & A. Gabetta). Platti: Cello Concertos in C major & C minor. Zani: Cello Concerto in A minor. Chelleri: Cello Concerto in G major
The latest instalment in a series exploring Vivaldi and his contemporaries
Wednesday, 15 January 2014
Sol Gabetta (cello) Cappella Gabetta/Andres Gabetta (director)
Vivaldi, Platti, Zani, Chelleri
SONY CLASSICAL 88697953502
This project’s third volume combines and contrasts concertos by Vivaldi with those of three compatriot contemporaries. Despite her use of an original 1781 Ferdinando Gagliano cello for some works (a 1752 G.B. Guadagnini graces the others), Sol Gabetta’s interpretations are unashamedly Romantic in technique and style, emphasising that there is more to historically informed performance than simply using period instruments. That said, Gabetta is as good a cellist as may be met in a long march – pitch-perfect (even in the often high tessitura of the first movement of Vivaldi’s Concerto for two mandolins RV532, in an arrangement for violin and cello soloists), cultured of tone, incisive but not edgy, and alert to every nuance. Some of her tempos exceed the speed limit – witness the finales of all four Vivaldi concertos – yet alongside playing of muscular virtuosity are some sublimely lyrical moments, notably in the aria-like Largo of RV422 and the central movements of Zani and Chelleri’s concertos. Chelleri’s opera-influenced work, recorded here for the first time, is a real gem.
The 16-piece orchestra provides buoyant, unanimous support, producing a bright, clean sound well captured by the resonant recording and contributing strikingly to the debate in the first two movements of Platti’s C minor Concerto.
From the January 2014 issue. Subscribe to The Strad or download our digital edition as part of a 30-day free trial.