The Strad's experts evaluate the latest string recordings
Britten: String Quartets nos.1–3
A new touchstone in an economical one-disc collection of Britten’s three numbered quartets
Monday, 03 March 2014
THE STRAD RECOMMENDS
HYPERION CDA 68004
Having passed through a period when I favoured the exceptionally dramatic view of Britten’s three quartets from the Belcea Quartet (EMI), I found more to enjoy with the arrival of a literal approach to the printed scores from the Maggini Quartet (Naxos). Now we have the best of both worlds in this new recording from the Takács Quartet.
Although at times the players employ daringly fast tempos, as in the opening movement of the First Quartet, their clarity and rhythmic exactitude remove any sense of undue haste. The third movement is also taken much quicker than in the Maggini’s more intense reading, and by lightening the texture they lessen the contrast with a finale that can easily sound frothy in other hands. The careful placement of the quiet cello pizzicatos that close the opening movement of the Second Quartet is indicative of the depth of thought that the Takács players bring to the whole cycle, and their final Chacony has plenty of urgency.
The Third Quartet, as we often find, is the most difficult to hold together, though here the problem is circumvented by adopting an energetic approach until the final Passacaglia, which is approached with an unadorned sadness. I would not want to be without the Maggini, but the Takács has set a new benchmark for these works, in excellent recorded sound.
Clip: Britten String Quartet no.1 in D major, op.25 – 1 Andante sostenuto – Allegro vivo
From the March 2014 issue. Subscribe to The Strad or download our digital edition as part of a 30-day free trial.